Comments on: Teaching About ‘Twilight’: Rape, Abuse, Pedophilia & Isolation http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse A Muslimah using crayons & humor to make sense of it all... Fri, 30 Jul 2010 01:20:15 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0 By: Claire http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse/comment-page-1#comment-453 Claire Tue, 06 Jul 2010 00:55:58 +0000 http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/content/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse-pedophilia-isolation.html#comment-453 What has the world come to that people will actually believe that twi-love is acceptable??? What has the world come to that people will actually believe that twi-love is acceptable???

]]> By: One Female Canuck http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse/comment-page-1#comment-289 One Female Canuck Mon, 24 May 2010 01:38:06 +0000 http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/content/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse-pedophilia-isolation.html#comment-289 Hey Arachnid - thank you for your comment. My apologies that you found the tone somewhat aggressive and sometimes insulting. It was indeed meant precisely as such - but to a very very particular group of individuals. However, I am pleased that some of the points resonated with you, still. Cheers. MARIA - I posted your comment for you. I don't know why you're having trouble posting comments. I've also linked it to your email so you know when people respond. Keep emailing me your comments and I will post them so long as the problem persists. I'll get to the rest of your email as soon as I can, and more privately. Re the other comments - I am so so so sorry about all of the comments gone missing. When I moved my blog over, there was only the day of the move minus 6 months' worth of comments that were transferred. We're still trying to figure out how to transfer all of the other hundreds of comments :( BOO. Love you and happy to see you back here...xoxoxoxo xox m Hey Arachnid – thank you for your comment. My apologies that you found the tone somewhat aggressive and sometimes insulting. It was indeed meant precisely as such – but to a very very particular group of individuals.

However, I am pleased that some of the points resonated with you, still. Cheers.

MARIA – I posted your comment for you. I don’t know why you’re having trouble posting comments. I’ve also linked it to your email so you know when people respond.

Keep emailing me your comments and I will post them so long as the problem persists. I’ll get to the rest of your email as soon as I can, and more privately.

Re the other comments – I am so so so sorry about all of the comments gone missing. When I moved my blog over, there was only the day of the move minus 6 months’ worth of comments that were transferred. We’re still trying to figure out how to transfer all of the other hundreds of comments :(

BOO.

Love you and happy to see you back here…xoxoxoxo

xox
m

]]> By: Maria Calvo http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse/comment-page-1#comment-288 Maria Calvo Mon, 24 May 2010 00:48:30 +0000 http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/content/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse-pedophilia-isolation.html#comment-288 I have to say I think this is a pretty funny entry unless you're one of the dolts who actually likes the series or a mother who doesn't discuss this with her kids or worse a parent who doesn't even bother reading this herself. Maybe you're just not used to the tone of writing on here - check out the other stuff and you'll understand her tone is pretty amazing and hilarious. She can defend herself, but I have been an avid reader of her blog for *years* because her writing is hilarious, spot on, and sometimes when necessary insulting to those who deserve it. Maha where are all of my original comments?? There was a whole discussion on here, where did it go? I keep emailing this article to friends every time a discussion comes up about Twilight, and I have been meaning to ask you about all of the comments because there are so many that are missing!!!! On ALL posts, dude, where did they go??????? Love you. Hugs, Maria I have to say I think this is a pretty funny entry unless you’re one of the dolts who actually likes the series or a mother who doesn’t discuss this with her kids or worse a parent who doesn’t even bother reading this herself. Maybe you’re just not used to the tone of writing on here – check out the other stuff and you’ll understand her tone is pretty amazing and hilarious. She can defend herself, but I have been an avid reader of her blog for *years* because her writing is hilarious, spot on, and sometimes when necessary insulting to those who deserve it.

Maha where are all of my original comments?? There was a whole discussion on here, where did it go? I keep emailing this article to friends every time a discussion comes up about Twilight, and I have been meaning to ask you about all of the comments because there are so many that are missing!!!! On ALL posts, dude, where did they go???????

Love you.

Hugs,
Maria

]]> By: X35 http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse/comment-page-1#comment-287 X35 Sat, 22 May 2010 15:18:22 +0000 http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/content/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse-pedophilia-isolation.html#comment-287 I was a bit taken aback by the tone of voice used here. I myself hate twilight and my children have no interest in reading it and none of us have seen the movies. Even so someone mentioned it how it was worse than that and so I ran across this blog and found it insulting. It was uncalled for, calling the audience/readers 'morons'. You insult people who you don't even know and then try and offer advice? There were a lot of good points you made, you made so many great points but so many of those points for me got lost in the insults you were spewing at the 'parents', assuming that they couldn't see what was there, etc. I was a bit taken aback by the tone of voice used here. I myself hate twilight and my children have no interest in reading it and none of us have seen the movies. Even so someone mentioned it how it was worse than that and so I ran across this blog and found it insulting.

It was uncalled for, calling the audience/readers ‘morons’. You insult people who you don’t even know and then try and offer advice? There were a lot of good points you made, you made so many great points but so many of those points for me got lost in the insults you were spewing at the ‘parents’, assuming that they couldn’t see what was there, etc.

]]> By: Brook http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse/comment-page-1#comment-247 Brook Sat, 27 Mar 2010 18:24:04 +0000 http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/content/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse-pedophilia-isolation.html#comment-247 Also if anyone had read the series they also would have known that Bella does in fact remember the night before. She states she remembers wanting him to hold her tighter and being happy when he did. She did not lose consciousness. The story also shows what true love is actually about, giving up what you have for that other person. Edward doesn't give her anything because it makes her unhappy to be given gifts. That's what true love is about. Making the other person happy. Also if anyone had read the series they also would have known that Bella does in fact remember the night before. She states she remembers wanting him to hold her tighter and being happy when he did. She did not lose consciousness. The story also shows what true love is actually about, giving up what you have for that other person. Edward doesn’t give her anything because it makes her unhappy to be given gifts. That’s what true love is about. Making the other person happy.

]]> By: Anonymous http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse/comment-page-1#comment-171 Anonymous Sat, 21 Nov 2009 17:59:39 +0000 http://www.onefemalecanuck.com/content/2009/03/teaching-about-twilight-rape-abuse-pedophilia-isolation.html#comment-171 10 Comments: Anonymous Anonymous said... Pretty good article. Interestingly, if you check out the comments of tween/teen girls a lot of them don’t seem to think that there’s a problem with the message of the film. In fact some think that Edward represents everything they want in a guy – the charismatic superman. A lot of them just want us to stop taking it so seriously and enjoy the film. There are even some mothers that don’t think that their daughter’s are influenced by gender imagery in books! We’re in trouble. S Fri Mar 27, 03:58:00 PM ********** Anonymous lily said... It's brutal that people don't think we no longer have to deal with gender issues. I guess everything was solved by the feminist revolution. -lily Mon Mar 30, 04:26:00 PM ********** Anonymous Maria Calvo said... The comments are crazier than the book it looks like!! Thanks for the link and I hope you found a way to unwind after this >>>>> it looks like you did in your post in rainy Toronto! Avoid all things Twilight, Maha :) Hugs, Maria Tue Mar 31, 02:45:00 PM ********** Anonymous Anonymous said... I vehemently agree with you on this one. Good call! Fri Apr 10, 10:22:00 PM ********** Anonymous Ian McLeod said... Thank you for writing this. I was preparing a rant about the very topic, only from a male perspective. Good guys, like me, have to compete with the image of Edward Cullen, and it's one of those things where a sane person would think there's no competition: a strong, charismatic, good, successful, and attractive man of conviction, versus an abusive, sly pretty-boy. We live in a psychotic society; Twilight isn't so much an influence on the zeitgeist as it is the accursed product thereof. You've won a new reader. Tue Apr 14, 06:58:00 PM ********** Blogger Clay said... The worst part is that most of the biggest fans are unwilling to hear anything on the matter other than what they think (which is normally mostly fluff anyway). Tue Apr 14, 08:49:00 PM ********** Blogger one female canuck said... Thank you to both Anons. Ian - welcome. New readers are ALWAYS welcome. Checked your space and the site you write for (American NonFiction). Pretty interesting stuff on there. I've bookmarked and shall return for more. And seriously dude - Rant away and I will link to your piece! Would love to read a more comprehensive (normal) male perspective, please. Hi again Clay - love love love that you comment...usually folks are so shy :) Have you heard about the Twi-People who have started to physically and violently attack non Twi-People? Craziness all across the board. I hope everyone's having a good week. xxoo Wed Apr 15, 10:15:00 PM ********** Blogger Clay said... No, I hadn't. It sounds like it's getting out of hand... Wed Apr 15, 11:29:00 PM ********** Anonymous Ian McLeod said... Thank you for checking out my work. I'll let you know as soon as I have my rant complete. I'm savoring this one. ;) Fri Apr 17, 11:59:00 PM ********** Anonymous Anonymous said... I'm so sad for my generation. There was a discussion between a group of people on the matter of whether Bella was raped or not. A twitard replied that even though she was unconscious she has basically forced it upon Edward to begin with and given consent, so it couldn't possible be considered rape. My reply was ".. uhh you're an idiot and know nothing about the law, because if you did you would understand that as soon as a person loses consciousness their consent is automatically withdrawn". Sat Nov 21, 07:59:00 AM 10 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said…

Pretty good article. Interestingly, if you check out the comments of tween/teen girls a lot of them don’t seem to think that there’s a problem with the message of the film. In fact some think that Edward represents everything they want in a guy – the charismatic superman. A lot of them just want us to stop taking it so seriously and enjoy the film. There are even some mothers that don’t think that their daughter’s are influenced by gender imagery in books!

We’re in trouble.

S
Fri Mar 27, 03:58:00 PM
**********

Anonymous lily said…

It’s brutal that people don’t think we no longer have to deal with gender issues. I guess everything was solved by the feminist revolution. -lily
Mon Mar 30, 04:26:00 PM
**********

Anonymous Maria Calvo said…

The comments are crazier than the book it looks like!!

Thanks for the link and I hope you found a way to unwind after this >>>>> it looks like you did in your post in rainy Toronto! Avoid all things Twilight, Maha :)

Hugs,
Maria
Tue Mar 31, 02:45:00 PM
**********

Anonymous Anonymous said…

I vehemently agree with you on this one. Good call!
Fri Apr 10, 10:22:00 PM
**********

Anonymous Ian McLeod said…

Thank you for writing this. I was preparing a rant about the very topic, only from a male perspective.

Good guys, like me, have to compete with the image of Edward Cullen, and it’s one of those things where a sane person would think there’s no competition: a strong, charismatic, good, successful, and attractive man of conviction, versus an abusive, sly pretty-boy.

We live in a psychotic society; Twilight isn’t so much an influence on the zeitgeist as it is the accursed product thereof.

You’ve won a new reader.
Tue Apr 14, 06:58:00 PM
**********

Blogger Clay said…

The worst part is that most of the biggest fans are unwilling to hear anything on the matter other than what they think (which is normally mostly fluff anyway).
Tue Apr 14, 08:49:00 PM
**********

Blogger one female canuck said…

Thank you to both Anons.

Ian – welcome. New readers are ALWAYS welcome. Checked your space and the site you write for (American NonFiction). Pretty interesting stuff on there. I’ve bookmarked and shall return for more.

And seriously dude – Rant away and I will link to your piece! Would love to read a more comprehensive (normal) male perspective, please.

Hi again Clay – love love love that you comment…usually folks are so shy :)
Have you heard about the Twi-People who have started to physically and violently attack non Twi-People? Craziness all across the board.

I hope everyone’s having a good week.

xxoo
Wed Apr 15, 10:15:00 PM
**********

Blogger Clay said…

No, I hadn’t. It sounds like it’s getting out of hand…
Wed Apr 15, 11:29:00 PM
**********

Anonymous Ian McLeod said…

Thank you for checking out my work. I’ll let you know as soon as I have my rant complete. I’m savoring this one. ;)
Fri Apr 17, 11:59:00 PM
**********

Anonymous Anonymous said…

I’m so sad for my generation. There was a discussion between a group of people on the matter of whether Bella was raped or not. A twitard replied that even though she was unconscious she has basically forced it upon Edward to begin with and given consent, so it couldn’t possible be considered rape. My reply was “.. uhh you’re an idiot and know nothing about the law, because if you did you would understand that as soon as a person loses consciousness their consent is automatically withdrawn”.
Sat Nov 21, 07:59:00 AM

]]>